top of page

What Sign Do I Need: ANSI or OSHA?

10 hours ago
8 min read

OSHA's sign rule is legally enforceable; ANSI Z535 is a voluntary design standard, not a law. A 2013 update allows OSHA-style or ANSI Z535-style signs. Here is how they look different, and which format may fit a workplace.

What is the difference between ANSI Z535 and OSHA safety signs?

OSHA, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, writes legally enforceable workplace rules. ANSI, the American National Standards Institute, publishes voluntary consensus standards, including the ANSI Z535 series that defines how safety signs and labels should be designed. The two are not the same kind of document, and one does not replace the other.

The enforceable general-industry sign rule is 29 CFR 1910.145. It covers the design, application, and use of accident-prevention signs and tags, and paragraph (a)(2) says all new signs and replacements of old signs shall follow those specifications.

Construction sites have a parallel rule at 29 CFR 1926.200.

ANSI Z535 is a seven-part series. As described on ANSI's overview of Z535.2-2023, Z535.2 covers environmental and facility safety signs and promotes a consistent visual layout.

ANSI's overview of Z535.4-2023 covers product safety signs and labels affixed to equipment, and notes that the series is developed by the National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA). The full standards are sold separately; this post uses ANSI's public descriptions, not the complete standard text.

Do I need OSHA signs or ANSI signs?

The legal duty is to meet the applicable OSHA rule. OSHA's 2013 direct final rule (78 FR 35559) added references to ANSI Z535.1-2006(R2011), Z535.2-2011 and Z535.5-2011 while retaining the earlier ANSI signage standards, "thereby providing employers an option to comply with the updated or earlier standards." Neither format is required in every workplace.

The color specifications in 1910.145 and the figure options in 1926.200 both allow the earlier format or the referenced Z535 editions. A catalog style name is not a substitute for checking the current official text.

VLG sells both styles. OSHA-style labels are described with OSHA-only wording, with no ANSI claim. ANSI-style labels may be called ANSI compliant and OSHA compliant.

The traditional format is grouped under OSHA safety labels.

The Z535-style layout is grouped under ANSI safety labels.

How do OSHA-style and ANSI Z535-style labels look different?

They are built from different layouts. A traditional OSHA-style sign is organized as a colored header panel plus a wording area, using the colors in 1910.145(d). An ANSI Z535-style label, as described in ANSI's Z535.4-2023 overview, is organized as a signal word panel — and, when used, a safety alert symbol — plus a message panel, and it may also include a symbol panel.

The header, or signal-word panel, is the first difference most people notice. For OSHA-style danger signs, 1910.145(d)(2) requires the colors red, black, and white. The current text does not reprint a header drawing; the former figure paragraphs at (d)(3) and (d)(5) are reserved. The traditional danger header is still spelled out in 1926.200(b)(2): red as the predominating color for the upper panel, a black outline on the borders, and a white lower panel for additional wording. For caution signs, 1910.145(d)(4) specifies a yellow background and a black panel with yellow letters; any letters used against the yellow background shall be black. Safety instruction signs under 1910.145(d)(6) use a white background and a green panel with white letters; any letters used against the white background shall be black.

On an ANSI Z535-style label, the signal word panel carries the signal word in sans-serif capital letters and, when used, the safety alert symbol — an equilateral triangle surrounding an exclamation mark. ANSI's Z535.4 overview describes DANGER as safety white letters on a safety red background and CAUTION as safety black letters on a safety yellow background. It describes a WARNING sign as a safety black triangle with a safety orange exclamation mark. ANSI's Z535.5-2022 overview, which uses the same signal-word color coding for tags and tapes, describes WARNING as safety black letters on a rectangular safety orange background. NOTICE, when used, appears in italicized safety white letters on a safety blue background.

A pictogram, or symbol panel, is treated differently too. 1910.145 does not require a pictogram on a danger, caution, or safety instruction sign. For tags, 1910.145(f)(4)(iii) allows the major message to be presented in pictographs, written text, or both. ANSI's Z535.4 overview treats the pictorial as optional: the hazard, the probable consequence, and how the hazard can be avoided are communicated through the word message and the optional use of a pictorial (symbol). When a safety symbol panel is used, that overview describes a safety black symbol on a safety white background, with other colors allowed for emphasis.

The message area is also arranged differently. 1910.145(e)(2) says the wording of any sign should be easily read and concise, contain sufficient information to be easily understood, make a positive rather than a negative suggestion, and be accurate in fact. It does not require a fixed three-part script. ANSI's Z535.4 overview says the label should alert people to the specific hazard, the degree or level of seriousness, the probable consequence of involvement with the hazard, and how the hazard can be avoided. The message panel may be horizontal or vertical, with safety black lettering on a safety white background or the reverse.

The same hazard can be shown in either format. An ANSI-style example is WARNING Pinch Point Labels #2 (SKU DEC-ANSI-WARNING-PINCH2-3X5), a 3 x 5 inch 10-pack at $19.99.

The OSHA-style Pinch Point Danger Safety Labels, SKU DEC-OSHA-DANGER-PINCHPOINT1-5X7, are a 5 x 7 inch 5-pack at $24.99. The two packs are not interchangeable just because both address pinch points; the signal word, size, pack count and layout differ. Choose the format the site specification calls for.

Which is better for my workplace: OSHA-style or ANSI-style labels?

Neither style is automatically better for every site. The duty is to meet the applicable OSHA rule. The more useful question is which format matches the existing signs, any specification that applies, and how the people on site need to read the message. Check the current official text and the site's own requirements rather than treating a catalog style name as the decision.

Industry and workplace type can narrow the choice. Equipment makers putting warnings on the product itself will usually look to ANSI Z535.4, which ANSI describes as the standard for product safety signs and labels affixed to a product. Facilities posting signs in the plant or yard will usually look to ANSI Z535.2 for that environment, or to the traditional OSHA format, especially if the existing signage is already in one style and the goal is to stay consistent as signs are replaced under 1910.145(a)(2). Construction work is covered by 1926.200, which allows danger and caution signs to follow either the older ANSI Z35.1-1968 figures or the figures in ANSI Z535.2-2011. General industry is covered by 1910.145, and the 2013 update gives employers the option to use the referenced Z535 standards or the earlier format.

Inspection and compliance needs matter as well. If a customer, contract, insurer, or corporate EHS specification calls out ANSI Z535, that specification is a purchase and design requirement to follow alongside the OSHA rule, not a substitute for it. If the need is simply to post a traditional OSHA-format danger, caution, or safety instruction sign, that earlier format remains an option the 2013 rule retained. A header style alone does not make a workplace compliant; assessment, wording, placement, and employee instruction still matter.

Other practical factors can decide the artwork. If the crew reads more than one language, a bilingual legend can make the message understandable to more of the people who will see it. If a pictogram will help, ANSI Z535-style labels are designed to include an optional symbol panel; 1910.145 does not require a pictogram on the sign itself. Mixing both styles in the same area can make a color or signal word harder to read consistently. If a site already has both, standardizing each line or area on one format as signs are replaced is the practical way to keep the system readable.

Is ANSI required by law?

No. ANSI Z535 standards are voluntary consensus standards, not statutes. OSHA may incorporate specific editions by reference, as it did in the 2013 update, but that does not make the entire Z535 series a law, and it does not require every employer to replace older OSHA-style signs that still meet the applicable rule. Check the current text of 1910.145 or 1926.200, and any state-plan or customer specification that applies to the site.

1910.145(c) still classifies signs according to use as danger signs, caution signs, and safety instruction signs. That classification has not been replaced by the ANSI Z535 system. A customer specification or a plant standard that calls for ANSI Z535-style artwork is a purchase requirement, not a substitute for reading the OSHA rule.

Are ANSI Z535 signs OSHA compliant?

ANSI Z535-style signs may be used to support OSHA's signage requirements under the option created by the 2013 update. A header style alone does not make a workplace compliant. Final compliance depends on the hazard assessment, correct wording, placement, and the employee instruction the rule requires, including 1910.145(c)(1)(ii) and (c)(2)(ii), which require employees to be instructed on what danger and caution signs mean.

The earlier OSHA-style format remains a valid option under that same 2013 rule. The choice between the two is a format decision, not a guarantee of compliance.

Does ANSI certify safety signs?

No. ANSI does not certify or approve individual safety signs or labels. "ANSI Z535-style" means the sign is designed according to the ANSI Z535 guidelines, as those guidelines are described by ANSI. It is not a government approval, and it is not a certification of the installation, the hazard assessment, or the workplace.

What signal words are used in ANSI Z535?

ANSI's Z535.2-2023 overview describes three hazard classifications denoted by DANGER, WARNING, and CAUTION, plus NOTICE for important information that is not hazard-related. The signal-word guide walks through that choice in more detail.

In that overview, DANGER is limited to the most extreme situations and means death or serious injury will result if the hazard is not avoided; WARNING means it could result; CAUTION means minor or moderate injury could result; and NOTICE is typically used for property damage, security, sanitation, and housekeeping rules.

OSHA's 1910.145(c) uses danger, caution, and safety instruction signs, not a WARNING sign class. WARNING appears in 1910.145(f)(7) for tags, which "may be used to represent a hazard level between 'Caution' and 'Danger,' instead of the required 'Caution' tag." Browse warning labels when a site specification uses the ANSI WARNING level.

VLG labels are Printed in the USA on premium low-shrinkage calendered vinyl with an industrial strength adhesive. A faded or peeling sign should be replaced; 1910.145(a)(2) requires replacements to meet the specification. This post does not assign a service life or an application temperature.

Questions about a custom legend or a mixed inventory can go through the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

What is OSHA?

OSHA is a federal regulatory agency. Its standards are legally enforceable and require employers to identify workplace hazards and warn employees of potential dangers, including through the sign specifications in 1910.145 and 1926.200.

What is ANSI?

ANSI publishes voluntary consensus standards, including the ANSI Z535 series, which defines how safety signs and labels should be designed. NEMA is the developer of the Z535 series.

What's the simplest way to stay aligned with the rules?

Identify the hazards as required by OSHA, choose wording that is easily read, concise and accurate, as 1910.145(e)(2) describes, and pick one format — OSHA-style or ANSI Z535-style — and keep it consistent. Check the current official text rather than relying on a catalog style name.

General safety information, not legal advice. Check the current official standards, applicable state-plan rules and local requirements with the responsible safety professional. A product style or purchase is not a certification of an installation.

Comments


bottom of page